Redefining Black Parenthood

“Let’s raise children who won’t have to recover from their childhoods.”

—Pam Leo

So this one late afternoon, I had come back home from doing some shopping downtown and having catch-up drinks with a friend. As my ritual, I went into my grandmother’s bedroom to greet her and make her aware of my return. As I stood next to her bed, she notices, for the first time, my faux sparkling, silver diamond ring on my left ring finger—which I wear to attempt to deter men from approaching or harassing me on the street.

“Hao Katli, did they engage you this afternoon?” she enquires in a startled voice.

I reply, “Aowo, mara Koko. You would probably know beforehand before I even get engaged that there is someone in my life.”

But in an ideal world right? Because truth is, if you are a “black kid”—whether you are as young as 18 or as grown-up and old as 28, these sort of topics give us ‘ama high-high’ when we have to bring them to the table with our parents.

The scenario with my granny really got me thinking, like, “Oh snap! What will I actually do when I meet a potential suitor, and we are talking about marriage? Or if I fall pregnant?”. I mean, I’m at that age that either could happen (well, maybe not the having babies part though). Do I gather the whole family and be like this is what is popping while my entire body is in knots and crosses, heart failure imminent from the rapid beats? I really need a manual on how to approach elders concerning serious and sensitive matters because I am 24 but I still find myself sweating when I need to tell my mom or granny something of a serious nature.

That, for me, is all that is wrong with black parenthood. So many of us fear our parents because things like communication without consequence are so unfamiliar with the way we relate to them. We try our level best to make things palatable for them so as not to offend them or be “disrespectful.”

How many times have we, as black children, had to pace up and down our rooms, trying to come up with the most agreeable way to bring up a hard matter or request before our parents? Changing words and phrases, practising the “humble and innocent look” before the mirror to at least lure in our parents to be a bit more attentive to us? How many times?
Fact is, we all know that black parents and listening are most certainly NOT in the same WhatsApp group. Barely five words through what you want to say, your mom or dad is already giving a long lecture that often is completely off-context to what you really wanted to say. This is why there will always be this barrier between black parents and their children. Our parents will never really get to know our deepest desires and the actual contents of our hearts because if something does not make sense to them, it is automatically ruled-out as wrong, and you dare not bring it up again.

And the problem lies with the hierarchies within our black families. Children are seen as the lowest and most inferior individuals, and then we wonder why as children and young people all our thoughts, emotions and feelings have almost always been invalidated, silenced and vilified because “you are just a child here.” And you see, every child wants to be heard, they want the assurance that: first and foremost they are seen, and they matter to their parents—and sadly so many of us have been deprived of that.

It is, for this reason, why I believe overcoming the hierarchical barrier between black parents and children is a necessary element of redefining black parenthood because many of us in black households grew up being told that parents are not our friends. And that for me, I believe has closed so many doors for parents and their daughters or sons to have completely open lines of honest, frank, sincere and authentic conversations. I know that so many of us wish if only our parents could be a little bit more open-minded and understanding so that we can open ourselves up to them a bit more—without fear.

I remember when I was a teenager I greatly envied my peers who had the liberty to openly share their tumultuous experiences with their parents while most of us if we dared try to do the same, we would be scolded and told: “You are too young to be thinking about such.” Or the peers whose parents allowed them to go to parties and even put it on themselves to drop them off or pick them up if the events ended late at night. While some of us the only way we could even ever enjoy such a teen luxury is if we sneak out of the house or fabricate some story about having to sleepover at a friend’s house to do a “project.” And it’s no wonder that it’s when I was a teenager that I felt the most alone and estranged from my own parents. Here I was, as a 16 or 19-year-old going through the most life-changing experiences and yet I could not share them with the people who are my first point of contact in this world because “your mom is not your friend.”

You know, this hierarchical barrier starts being tricky when you are an adult. You grow up, and suddenly one party (usually the parent) expects the other to be completely open when the relationship has been heavy-laden with so much censorship and secrecy for decades. I find it difficult how that would work when years on end, as the son or daughter, you had been scolded for bringing up uncomfortable topics.

How can we then heal as the black community, when the most fundamentally crucial aspect of any society, i.e., family, is the site of oppressive silencing in our community? Often the topics that are considered the most taboo are the ones which so many of us are dying from. But our screams and cries are often invalidated and seen as an inconvenience.

And I wish as black kids we would experience the sort of relationship with our parents that never requires us to ever censor ourselves in fear of consequences. Imagine if conversations around sex and sexuality were not met with discomforting vagueness? Or being able to have intimate exchanges with our parents, where they know us deeply, and we know them, too? I long for that, quite intently.

At some point, we also need to talk about how within a black family context, we have for the longest time, valorized “strict parenting.” But how strict parenting has often been synonymous with controlling and violent parenting (yes, I said it, black parenting is downright violent). Words and phrases like “tough love” have always been used to mask the emotional, mental and even physical abuse that our parents often inflict on us. And our parents tell us that it is how they were raised. “Look how we turned out,”  they say to try and okay the abuse they endured from their parents and elders; insinuating that they turned out fine. But they are not fine. We sit down with our uncles and aunts whom our grandfathers would beat until they bled, and you realise that they are far from being fine, they are silently traumatised. And that’s when we understand that their traumas are passed down to us, they re-enact the abuse that they endured, but in different ways.

 With all of this, I feel that I have only touched the surface of the toxicity of black parenting that so many of us have experienced. There are so many things that we have taken and bore through from our parents that we wouldn’t dare tolerate if we experienced them in any of our other significant relationships. That, therefore, points to us the profoundly toxic nature that black parenthood tends to exude. It is, thus, so important that we all do the work of conversing and reimagining ways that we can start emulating a different and healthier form of black parenting. I believe that when we resolve ourselves to heal the black family and its parenthood, it is only then that we can start going through the journey of breeding a healthier black nation.

And being at a place in my life where, a few years from now, I’ll have children of my own, it has also forced me to look at the ways that I’ve related to my own parents and how they’ve related to me. With that, I am putting it on my own shoulders to do the hard emotional and mental work of modelling to my kids a different kind of black parenting. The kind of parenting that does not insist on them being less inferior or less important to me. But the kind of parenting that assures them, in every way and always, that their voices are valid, their experiences are valid. That as their mother, I’m not there to be a dictator or police their every thought, action and choice, but to be a loving guide. That is how I hope to contribute to redefining the experience of black parenthood, at least for my children and every young person who will ever look to me as their mother, parent or guardian. And I say it is a hard emotional and mental work because I am not naive at the reality of displaying something that one has never witnessed. But I firmly believe that it is possible, it is possible for us to work on emulating a new kind of black parenthood collectively.

Loved what you just read?

Subscribe so you never miss a post...
Sign up with your email address to receive exclusive updates in your inbox!

What do you think?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Zolisa Welani
    Sep 21, 2017

    You probably don’t know me and I’ve never met you in person. I really enjoyed reading this, it was very enlightining and I could relate to most of what you wrote.
    You seem to know just the right words to express how one feels. I wish I had this skill. Thanks again for this piece.

    • Katlego Llale
      Sep 21, 2017

      Hey Zolisa,

      Thank you for taking the time to comment and sharing with me your resonance with what I wrote. I am also greatly humbled by some of the words you have expressed, much appreciated.
      It’s only my pleasure and thanks to you too for taking the time to read the post.

  • shadi
    Sep 22, 2017

    Hi katli
    I always read your blogs but I it hard to comment because somehow I feel like you and I are the same person going through the same thing but at a different time.
    As a mother of I’ve always thought of what you have highlighted and it is all true although we try to be open but there’s always a barrier or limit to what you say and that doesn’t constitute as being open really.
    I’m going through a very difficult time right now and I find myself sitting in a shrinks office everytime life gets overwhelming instead of turning to my parents for an ear and guidance.
    Katli may you grow and continue to inspire us God bless you abundantly.

    • Katlego Llale
      Sep 27, 2017

      Hey Shadi,

      Thank you for taking the time to finally comment, much appreciated. And it is also a great delight to know that you share resonance with most of the experiences that I write about.

      Also, I think it is important that you are patient with yourself. And even though I am not a parent myself, as yet, I believe/imagine that good parenting involves being mindful of our mistakes and taking an initiative to be better at it because we won’t get things right the first time around and that is perfectly okay.

      I’m sorry that you are going through a tough time and you are not able to go to your parents, it must be a lonely feeling. I hope that the relationship between you and your parents will strengthen and mend where you need it most to be.

      Thank you for your words and blessings.

      Keep well.

      • shadi
        Sep 27, 2017

        Thank you

  • Sibusiso Radebe
    Sep 24, 2017

    I definitely feel you my friend.. At 24 my mother heard from my aunt(her younger sister) that I was dating someone because for the life of me, I couldn’t bring myself to tell her. The space to do that was never there, and at that point in time, she expected that, after growing up being silenced, I would have miraculously developed communication skills overnight and now include in my relationship discussions…
    This toxicity is real hey, and the saddest part is that our parents don’t even realize that what they think is right is actually stifling us. That’s if they are not plain out refusing to admit to it, if they do realize that it’s toxic. We have a responsibility therefore, to raise our kids in a safe way that puts value on their humanity and identity.

    • Katlego Llale
      Sep 27, 2017

      Yoh my friend, I can relate so much with what you shared. It is such a difficult feat to bring up these kinds of things to our parents. They are often not the most approachable of people as they often raise us in such a manner that we fear them and fear in any relationship hinders vulnerability and complete openness because you fear how the person will react to you. And its the same dynamic with our parents.

      I think our parents need to firstly acknowledge to themselves that they are not perfect and learn to apologise and learn from us as their children. And recognise that will not in any way take away their position as parents in our lives.

      But I do hope we will do better by our children and raise them in such a way that we would have wished to be raised or in a way that would be most optimum for their growth in every aspect of their lives.

      Thank you Sbu for sharing your thoughts!

  • Bryanna
    Aug 5, 2020

    Oh my gosh, your content is so relevant to my life right now. My brother and I had this exact conversation today about how harmful our parent’s parenting has been towards us in the past. And, we also pieced together how many of the issues that plague our adult lives stemmed as a direct result of it. These conversations are so necessary for our community, and it’s interesting that recently my own mother has been open with me about how she was damaged from my grandparents’ parenting. It needs to stop, and I definitely hope to break these generational barriers when I have children because it is so damaging and harmful.

    • Katlego Llale
      Aug 7, 2020

      Yaay! I am so glad that you stumbled upon my blog, Bryanna, and it could find resonance with you and where you currently at.

      These are truly conversations that we need to have even more so, with our parents themselves.

      However, I think our generation is headed in the right direction and will revolutionize parenting. Just as reflected in your conversation with your brother, we can reflect and see all the ways that the parenting we received is the root of some of our problems as adults. And because of that, it is much easier for us to not repeat or perpetuate the same harmful parenting practices.

Loving Ourselves When It Matters Most
Redefining Black Parenthood